As the film turns 20, Hasitha Fernando looks at the story behind Tenacious D in The Pick of Destiny…
Blending irreverent humor, outrageous stoner comedy and some head bangin’ hard-rock anthems, Tenacious D in The Pick of Destiny brought the talents of musical comedy duo Jack Black and Kyle Gass to the big screen in a wildly entertaining rock ‘n’ roll adventure. As the comedy rock opera celebrates its 20th anniversary we look back at the making of this unique cult classic and why its appeal still endures…
HBO was the reason we got Tenacious D in The Pick of Destiny
Tenacious D is a two-piece musical act comprising of Jack Black and Kyle Gass, both of whom are equally talented musicians and entertainers in their own right. Formed in 1994, the comedic musical duo achieved popularity with the 1997 release of their self-titled HBO TV show. The show – which aired from November 28, 1997, to March 15, 2000, on HBO – was a surreal, half-hour comedy series that comprised of three episodes in total, with each episode being split into two separate vignettes. Black and Gass also served as the co-creators of the show, along with stand-up comedians David Cross and Bob Odenkirk who hosted the then popular sketch comedy TV series Mr. Show. When HBO approached Black and Gass to renew their show into a ten-episode series, the pair rejected the offer because one of the networks’ conditions involved relinquishing their executive producer roles and having them to focus strictly on the song writing aspect. As a result, the show wrapped after its initial run and our creative pair set about laying the groundwork for a feature film based around the show’s concept.
Production of the feature film was stuck in development for several years
Although both Jack Black and Kyle Gass had always envisioned a feature film to be the pinnacle of the duo’s act, their dream didn’t become a reality until much later. After severing all ties with HBO the pair tried conceptualizing numerous ideas for the plot of their film. One of the stories the two played around with centered around the lost city of Atlantis and meeting Ronnie James Dio before embarking on a road trip to Miami. This idea was scrapped later on. Scott Aukerman and BJ Porter, who collaborated with Odenkirk on Mr. Show, wrote a draft for them somewhere in the early 2000’s but this too was discarded. Afterwards the band was in negotiations with British-based Working Title Films to write and distribute a Tenacious D feature film but this too didn’t pan out, as Black and Gass were dissatisfied with the writer’s ideas. Things took a positive turn in February 2003, when the band signed with New Line Cinema to produce their feature film. Liam Lynch, who had previously directed Tenacious D’s music video “Tribute”, came on board to helm the effort while he, Black and Gass took on scripting duties and producing the movie as well. Later that same year, Black confirmed that the title of the film would be Tenacious D in The Pick of Destiny and that the story would center around the band’s search for a legendary guitar pick.
The sections in the movie about Jack Black’s childhood were greatly fictionalized
Although Jack Black essentially plays himself in Tenacious D in The Pick of Destiny, it was a greatly fictionalized version of himself that he played in the movie. For example in the beginning of the film, where he sings about his extremely strict Catholic family upbringing and their less than enthusiastic perspective regarding rock music, it was all fictional. In reality, Black’s family was largely supportive of his musical pursuits and acting career. The actor was also raised in Santa Monica, California and not in Kickapoo, Missouri like as told in the story. Kickapoo isn’t a made-up name either, it is a very real section belonging to Springfield, Missouri.
Kyle Gass packed some extra pounds to play the role in the film
In the band Kyle Gass plays the lead guitarist whilst Jack Black provides the vocals for the songs they compose. Gass has always had a larger appearance throughout his life but for his role in Tenacious D in The Pick of Destiny, the guy put on an extra 50 lbs. with a high-calorie diet made up of Jr. Western bacon cheeseburgers, chocolate milkshakes, seasoned curly fries and extra helpings of Cherries Jubilee. In subsequent years, Gass started focusing on his health and underwent a dramatic weight loss transformation.
Meat Loaf had not sung in a movie since The Rocky Horror Picture Show
The late Marvin Lee Aday professionally known as Meat Loaf was an artist and singer who had sold more than 100 million records worldwide, making him one of best-selling music artists of all time. Meat Loaf’s biggest hit was the rock ballad “I’d Do Anything For Love (But I Won’t Do That)” which won the Grammy Award for Best Solo Rock Vocal Performance. The talented artist has also appeared in over 50 movies and TV shows over the years either as himself or embodying different characters. Some of his notable works in film include The Rocky Horror Picture Show, Wayne’s World, Spice World and Fight Club. In Tenacious D in The Pick of Destiny, Meat Loaf played Jack Black’s stern, overly religious father and during that sequence set in the beginning of the movie, his character was required to engage in some singing. The performer was initially reluctant to take the part as he preferred to be seen as a serious actor in the industry. But in the end Meat Loaf threw in the towel and took the role, marking the first time he sang in a movie since The Rocky Horror Picture Show in 1975.
Ronnie James Dio and David Grohl had fun with the cameos they played
Ronnie James Dio was a heavy metal singer considered by most to be one of the greatest and most influential rock singers of all time. Dio was part of many well-recognized acts such as Rainbow, Black Sabbath, Dio and Heaven & Hell, before his untimely demise in 2010. Dio appeared as himself in the film during Jack Black’s “bedroom poster come-to-life” sequence, advising him to go to Hollywood. It’s in this sequence that Dio also had to sing a song along with Black. At the beginning of the recording session, Dio asked for the music to be played back for preparation purposes and sung his part, but the take was deemed perfect by Black and the sound engineer, that no further take was needed. Dio, of course wanted to attempt a few more takes as he was having fun, but Black denied the singer’s request. Foo Fighter’s David Grohl was another prominent rock talent who had a fun cameo in the movie. In the movie, the musician portrayed Satan, hidden beneath layers of prosthetics and makeup, and it is he who provides the gnarly vocals and insane drum track for the climactic “Beelzeboss (The Final Showdown)” rock-off.
Ben Stiller had multiple parts to play in Tenacious D in: The Pick of Destiny
Ben Stiller was busy in front of and behind the camera during the making of Tenacious D in The Pick of Destiny. Stiller executive produced the feature through his Red Hour Films production company whilst also playing an important yet minor-role in the film as the unhinged Guitar Center Sales Store Guy who recounts the dark history of the Pick of Destiny to Jack Black and Kyle Gass. Stiller had previously cameoed in the music video of Tenacious D’s hit song “Tribute” playing a disturbed passersby.
Box- office failure, mixed reviews and the birth of a cult classic
Made on a budget of $20 million Tenacious D in The Pick of Destiny went on to tragically underperform at the worldwide box-office, only grossing $13.9 million. Although DVD/digital sales of the film added a further $7.6 million to the movie’s overall earnings making a profit of over $1.5 million, it was still categorized as a box-office bomb. The disappointing box-office return certainly took a toll on Jack Black who vowed to never write a script again as he didn’t want a retread of what happened with Tenacious D in The Pick of Destiny. On review aggregator site Rotten Tomatoes the film holds an approval rating of 53% based on 124 reviews with an average rating of 5.6/10. The website’s critic consensus sums up the effort in the following manner: “Tenacious D fans will find this movie hilarious; everybody else will see only a low-brow concept movie and a small assembly of jokes stretched past the 100 minute mark.” Regardless of what film critics thought during its debut, the movie found its true audience through home media and word-of-mouth, creating a dedicated fan base all around the world and effectively transforming a box-office bomb into a beloved cult classic. Even the band embraced the movie’s unconventional success story incorporating the effort’s rocky start and disappointing box-office return when promoting their 2012 album Rize of the Fenix.
What are your thoughts on Tenacious D in The Pick of Destiny? Let us know on our socials @FlickeringMyth…
Hasitha Fernando is a part-time medical practitioner and full-time cinephile. Follow him on Twitter via @DoctorCinephile for regular updates on the world of entertainment.